"When I gave people food, they called me a saint. When I asked why people had no
food, they called me a communist." -- Helder Camara
The main problem of production in capitalism
is the transformation of a necessity into a commodity.
Every human being needs food, clothing
and shelter to protect them and to be healthy.
Food, clothes, houses and medicine are products
that every human being requires to meet the basic
needs of life. They are essential because of their
use value.
But in capitalism, the bosses sell them to us for
their exchange value, i.e. for the profits that they
get from these products. If there is no profit for
them, the products don't get to our homes, even
when they're piled up in warehouses, or thrown
away. In other words, if we don't have the money,
we can't buy them. This is the main contradiction
in the system of capitalist production.
The ideas that we reflect here are the result of
collective discussions with comrades of ICWP
and Red Flag readers from several countries of a
communist analysis of food production, which
was presented to comrades and friends at a recent
meeting in Mexico.
Capitalism: Food to Sell
In capitalism, the goal of food production is
not to have a healthy lifestyle, but to generate
profits. This brings great suffering to the working
class. Currently, 50% of the working class in the
world (three and a half billion people) are malnourished:
hungry, undernourished or obese.
They suffer from poisoning, allergies or diseases
such as cancer, and one third of the population
survives on $ 2 a day. To make matters worse, of
all the food produced by workers in the bosses'
industries, 60% is thrown in the garbage because
it is not sold. This amount is enough to feed a
population higher than the current world population,
the estimated population by mid-century (11
billion people).
Big corporations own 80% of the land on
which food is grown. They have cornered the
water for irrigation and have the technology, inputs,
knowledge and laws to dominate the entire
food system.
But to maintain profits and compete with other
bosses, they have to invest in technology, improved
varieties, transgenics, agrochemicals and
they must pay farmworkers less.
Racism, sexism and nationalism are fundamental
for them to exploit us. Women and children
are superexploited in the harvest of berries
in Mexico. Or undocumented immigrants in
Brazil—mostly indigenous farmworkers from
Bolivia, Uruguay and Paraguay. The bosses in the
U.S., in China and in all countries have their own
undocumented workers.
Communism: Food to Eat
Use value will be the main thing in communism.
We will use the most benign environments
to produce food. In each climate (tropical, temperate
or desert) suitable crops will be produced,
and distributed to regions where they cannot be
cultivated.
The same person over a period of time will
produce food, at other times will produce clothing
or build houses, and if needed can take care
of sick people. We will do all physical and mental
work. Both will be equally appreciated, and we
will never value one over the other. We will work
freely, without money, without bosses, without
borders, without racism, and without sexism. We
will be one family.
Whether or not we understand the contradiction
in capitalism leads us to two paths. Not understanding
it keeps us tied to the illusion that
capitalism can be reformed, to create a "more humane
capitalism." Environmentalists, advocates
of permaculture and agro-ecologists like Vandana
Shiva, for example, passionately criticize and describe
capitalism to mass audiences, but do not
understand or explain the main contradiction, so
they never speak of imperialism and war as inevitable
to the nature of capitalism. Understanding
this contradiction leads to communist
revolution, because we know that capitalism has
no solution. Only communism can meet all the
needs of the working class. Join ICWP!
|